Read Digital Edition


ADS BY GOOGLE
Top Three Links You Must Click On


i-Technology Viewpoint: Attack of the Blogs
Jeremy Geelan Takes A Brief Sideways Look at Daniel Lyons' Much-Discussed Forbes Article About "Attack Blogs"

Attack of the Blogs: But “Blogs Don't Kill People, Idiots Do”

What’s the key issue underlying Daniel Lyons’s controversial “Attack of the Blogs” article in this month’s Forbes? In my view his piece, with its knowingly provocative title, has provoked much heat…but so far very little light.

So let’s try and redress that, however slightly! ;-)

Blogging is a hot topic in the professional news-gathering community right now and one of the simplest ways to understand all the fuss (on both sides) is to think for a moment of why Microsoft feels so threatened by Linux. The professional journalist community, if you accept this analogy, is like Microsoft, and the blogging community is like Linux, it holds out the promise of providing a product for free that is at least equal to and very possibly superior to the commercial version.

If you hold with this interpretation, then it becomes at once easier to understand why a professional writer (Dan Lyons) writing for a commercial publication (Forbes magazine) might have a vested interest in publishing an article turning the spotlight on what he terms “attack blogs” – that’s to say, blogs used by for example rival companies “as a weapon, unleashing swarms of critics on their rivals.”

But Lyons himself writes in Forbes that attack blogs “are but a sliver of the rapidly expanding blogosphere,” so let’s concentrate instead on the fact that 100,000 new blogs are said to be created every day – that’s more than one new blog per second. (These stats are derived from the San Francisco firm Technorati, which tracks the content of 20 million active blogs.) Does the blogosphere, viewed from this perspective, amount to a threat to paid-for journalism?

Personally, I think that’s the wrong question. To my mind, it’s a little like asking, does the availability of free drinking water threaten the existence of Perrier? The answer is no; they are two separate things. People will always want journalism as well as blogalism, for the simple reason that, while from a paid-for news product one has the right to demand standards of accuracy, decency and compliance with ethical standards; from a blog one can demand none of the above.

Which is not to claim that the vast majority of blogs aren’t both accurate and ethical; they are. Nor that there is no such thing as rogue journalism; there is. But blogalism isn’t predicated in any way on professional accreditation, so there really is no form of sanction for breaches of any sort, whether of accuracy, decency, or even privacy. The rule is simply, “If you don’t like what you’re reading here, just stop opening this site in your browser or receiving this RSS feed.” First Amendment rights are a wondrous thing; but they are no great guarantee of unblemished reporting.

As the world continues to spin ever-faster, with issues like globalization, outsourcing, and disintermediation all intertwining in a sometimes almost bewildering variety of ways, and with consequences both foreseen and unforeseen, I would go so far as to say not only that journalism will continue to be both valued and purchased by readers worldwide, but that the thirst for “mediated” reporting will increase as a function of the expansion of the blogosphere. When you can find ten thousand views on anything, it becomes more important and valuable, not less, to consult the view of a single trusted source. Or, more likely, a small group of different trusted sources, just to be on the safe side.

So it is not, in my opinion, a fear of pending redundancy that motivated Daniel Lyons and/or his publisher Steve Forbes to highlight the pernicious nature of “attack blogging,” so much as an inevitable curiosity about a phenomenon that technology has inadvertently enabled.

Call it the Law of Unintended Consequences in operation. Just as the inventor of the automobile doubtless had no intention of facilitating the one-night stand, neither did Dave Winer set out to foment Reckless, Stupid Syndication. It isn’t blogs that “attack,” it’s people. Or rather a sub-section of people: idiots.

About Jeremy Geelan
Jeremy Geelan is Sr. Vice-President of SYS-CON Media & Events. He is Conference Chair of the all-new International Cloud Computing Conference & Expo series, of the International Virtualization Conference & Expo series, of AJAXWorld RIA Conference & Expo series, and of the long-running SOAWorld Conference & Expo series. He's founder of Cloud Computing Journal, Web 2.0 Journal, AJAX & RIA Journal and other leading SYS-CON titles. From 2000-6, as first editorial director and then group publisher of SYS-CON Media, he was responsible for the development of all new titles and i-Technology portals for the firm, and regularly represents SYS-CON at conferences and trade shows, speaking to technology audiences both in North America and overseas. He is executive producer and presenter of "Power Panels with Jeremy Geelan" on SYS-CON.TV.

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

Register | Sign-in

Reader Feedback: Page 1 of 1

If you go to http://www.forbes.com/execpicks/forbes/2005/1114/128sidebara.html you will note that it is used as a vehicle to attack Pamela Jones of Groklaw.

It also says that your owner said the following: "What are my options?We have criminal people who were taking us hostage, trying to destroy my business,"says Sys-Con Chief Fuat Kircaali.

If Lyons is quoting correctly, and the whole editors walk out - which was rather well reported - did not happen, then I expect that your paper will be receiving comments soon. I also expect this to blow up in Sys-con's face.

When this happens, please thank Mr. Lyons for misreporting the facts. Again.

||| How about the whole issue of anonymous blogging, you don't mention that...? |||

Anonymous dissent is a long and noble tradition, just as insult and invective were the stock-in-trade of the English political essayists of the 18th century

How about the whole issue of anonymous blogging, you don't mention that...?


  Subscribe to our RSS feeds now and receive the next article instantly!
In It? Reprint It! Contact advertising(at)sys-con.com to order your reprints!
Subscribe to the World's Most Powerful Newsletters

ADS BY GOOGLE
Likewise, which authenticates Linux, Unix and Mac users with Microsoft Active Directory, has started...
The new widgetry features multi-cluster support and enhanced concurrency management to improve scali...
In the wake of the financial crisis and its attendant repercussions across the global economy, the U...
It says Traffic Server enables the session management, authentication, configuration management, loa...
The company says “extensive collaboration with large enterprise beta customers, such as Comviva, Hos...
It claims the widgetry, which lets Mac users run Windows and Linux alongside Mac OS X, is faster, sm...
Cisco CEO John Chambers, who has turned into something of an economic oracle probably because he is ...
Microsoft’s browser rivals aren’t satisfied with the tentative “ballot screen” settlement that the c...
Do you have digital camera? Do you record special events around you? Publish them on your website wi...
According to Aster Data, applications need to go to “Big Data,” not the other way around. And to do ...
The Cloud Computing Conference and Expo in Santa Clara has come to an end, leaving a fair share of o...
As virtualization entered the data center it became an accidental standard bearer for network automa...
In iPhone Tips, Tricks & Apps for Business Executives, the analyst shares quick and easy ways to tru...
Investors who are serious about maximizing returns and minimizing risks will find McWilliams' ongoin...
The talk at the Cloud Computing Expo this week in Santa Clara was all about enterprise cloud adoptio...
RASS and 6fusion USA, Inc. announced a partnership to co-deliver cloud hosted desktop and server app...
I can't let this experience go undocumented. I am sitting in Starbucks drinking a Mocha, writing a b...
The first "Ulitzer New Media Power Panel" took place today at the Santa Clara Convention Center in S...
A majority of executives polled by Deloitte (60.9 percent) believe cloud computing will be a transfo...
Google Thursday open sourced its Closure JavaScript tools – a compiler, a cross-browser, server-agno...